© Copyright 2012 Roy Tennant. FreeLargePhotos.com |
Having grown up in a sedate suburb of a small Pennsylvania city, my time in NYC/NJ developed certain characteristics that I recognized as responses to this unfamiliar, hyper-stimulating, gritty, and somewhat aggressive environment. One response to feeling very vulnerable in a place where danger seemed to lurk around every corner (remember NYC in the early '80s?) resulted in my total mental isolation from the hundreds of strangers who crossed my path everyday. I made no eye contact; I assumed a conspicuous appearance of oblivion to those around me (all the while on heightened alert for any abnormal and possibly threatening behavior); and in many cases, I displayed hostile signs of shutting people out: a well-placed scowl to the skeevie guy sitting opposite me on the subway; a brief and perfunctory nod to the token lady in the kiosk; a gruff order placed to the hot dog vendor. (Yeah, I ate them and survived! Shocking!)
It wasn't until I left the city and moved to a small college town that I realized how steeled against the potential dangers around me I had become. It is hard to go out of your way to be kind and courteous to others when dropping your hostile defenses could result in losing your matching handbag to a quick-thinking street thug. (I actually witnessed just such an event right in front of me in the middle of the afternoon. Remember, this was the early '80s before Mayor Guiliani cracked down on the rampant street crime in the city.) In my new small-town home, I realized I no longer needed a death grip to hold my purse; I didn't need to muscle my way ahead of people to enter a building or elevator or public transportation; it was OK and even pleasant to politely ask for menu items at the local cafe and offer a genuine and friendly smile upon receipt. I slowly abandoned my aggressive posturing and gratefully relinquished this toxic lifestyle.
Now the Italian Mama revels in witnessing unnecessary acts of kindness, helpful or courteous actions that are completely uncalled for by any kind of handicap or need, but done for the sheer joy of watching people's reactions to the unexpected gift. I suppose people who enjoy city living manage to muster the courage to commit these types of acts and still feel safe. I never found the strength to sustain the confidence such neighborly behavior requires. Maybe I was never meant to live in a big city. Or maybe I just wasn't old enough.
This is a stunning piece of writing--both sociologically and emotionally--that I LOVED. You expose the myth and danger of the NYC fantasy! I wanted to read another chapter just about this girl on the subway in her navy heels. I also realized the connection that sometimes folks aren't kind simply because they don't feel safe. I think this explains some of the behavior of children in my life. Instead of asking them to "just be kind" to one another, I need to probe deeper and discern where they feel unsafe. What do you think?
ReplyDeleteI know this may sound Polly-Annish, but I believe that kids are naturally warm hearted and good and social. Any anti-social behavior comes from their environment (barring exceptional people born with brains that function atypically). What kid wouldn't want to connect with another kid or a friendly adult?! But acts of kindness and behavior that extend us beyond ourselves require a certain amount of confidence that our reaching out will not be spurned or abused. When we get older and gain more self-assurance we either don't care if we get spurned or know that we won't get spurned because of positive experiences (or both). But children don't have those experiences and may not have the self-possession to feel like they will be OK even if their advances are rebuffed. (Think about asking someone on a date; you feel the need to muster the courage b/c you know how much it will hurt if you are rejected.)
DeleteI think you are spot on in approaching children's social behavior in terms of what they might be fearful of. People who don't appear to be kind may simply be afraid and defensive.